Pros And Cons Of Crate Training

by admin
dog crate training pros and cons


Dog Crate Training Pros And Cons: Crate training is both a popular and a controversial topic. Some people love crate training and swear by it. Others simply cannot imagine putting their puppy in a “cage.” Regardless of everything you have read or heard, you really have to consider the pros and cons of crate training and whether it is something you believe is right for you and for your puppy.


If introduced the right way, a crate can provide a safe haven for your puppy, a place where he turns to feel secure. You can learn more about crate training your dog with the help of this course.


It’s something that we did with Coco when we got her from the rescue as she was not toilet trained at all. It worked extremely well for us, and it was much better for Coco herself not to be messing on the floor – as it actually used to upset her. Now Joey is the next one to be crate trained. He seems to be getting on well, although he has been a slightly slower learner than Coco.

Dog Crate Training Pros And Cons


Choosing the Right Crate


The foundation of successful crate training lies in selecting the appropriate crate. The size is paramount: it should be large enough for the dog to stand, turn around, and lie down comfortably. However, it shouldn’t be so expansive that they can soil one end and sleep on the other.



dog crate training pros and cons



Materials also matter. While wire crates offer good ventilation, plastic ones can feel more den-like, providing that essential den instinct environment. The choice often hinges on the dog’s preference and the prevailing climate. Resources like Choosing the Right Crate provide invaluable insights into making the best selection. Ensuring your dog’s comfort and safety starts with the right crate choice. (Dog Crate Training Pros And Cons)


Read more: Is Crate Training Necessary? Is It Cruel? 17 Pros, Cons & Benefits of Crate Training a Dog



Avoiding Negative Association

The crate should always symbolize a positive space. Never resort to using it as a punitive measure. If signs of distress or anxiety emerge, like puppy whining, it’s imperative to pinpoint and address the underlying cause rather than enforcing crate time. Ensuring the crate remains a haven rather than a prison for your crate-trained pup is essential for its success.


One Dog Per Crate Rule

While crates offer a personal space for dogs, it’s essential to remember the rule of “one dog per crate.” Some owners, in an attempt to save space or money, might be tempted to house multiple dogs in a single crate. 


Increased Stress and Aggression: Even the most amicable dogs can become territorial in confined spaces, leading to potential fights or aggressive behavior.



Read more: Pros and Cons of Crate Training: Things Dog Owners Should Consider


Lack of Personal Space: Just as humans value personal space, dogs too need their own area to relax and feel secure away from other dogs. Sharing a crate can deprive them of this essential comfort.


Health Concerns: If one dog falls ill, sharing a crate can expedite the spread of diseases or parasites to the other. (Dog Crate Training Pros And Cons)


Pros Of Crate Training


  1. Crate training often makes the toilet training process easier.

Teaching a puppy how and when to use the toilet can be a difficult and stressful process for both the puppy and you.

If your puppy has the right size crate – not too big that he will be encouraged to use part of it as the toilet but big enough to allow him to stretch out – he will eventually learn to control his bladder and to go outside when it is time to use the toilet.

A dog walker, who visits during the day when you are not home, can also help speed up the toilet training process.


  1. The crate provides the puppy with his own personal space.

Everyone in a family has his or her own personal space, and it’s only fair your puppy has a space to claim as his own. A crate can do just that. He will have a safe, quiet place to lie down and relax away from all the noise of a typical day.


  1. Crate training can help curb separation anxiety.

Some puppies have a difficult time being away from their families. If introduced the right way, a crate can provide a safe haven for your puppy, a place where he turns to feel secure.


  1. When you have to board your dog.

 Especially if you go with a traditional boarding where they’re going to be confined, even if it’s only at night, if your dog already has a good association with the crate with, there’s an extra peace of mind knowing that he’s going to be comfortable there. (Dog Crate Training Pros And Cons)


When I used to board dogs in my house I didn’t require a crate (with the exception of puppies not yet potty trained)  But if they were crate trained, I highly recommend bringing their crate because the dogs who slept in the crates at night made the best transition to the new environment. I very rarely had any kind of whining or anxiety.



dog crate training pros and cons



Cons of Crate Training


  1. Your puppy may be unhappy at first.

And, if your puppy is unhappy before he gets used to the crate, you are certainly going to hear about it. He’s likely going to whine, yelp, howl, and bark – maybe even all at the same time, creating sounds you may never have heard before – in an attempt to get you to open the door. Can you handle that stab in the heart you might feel when you hear your puppy whining for your attention and to let him out?


  1. Your puppy may view it as punishment.

The crate can be considered a punishment by some puppies. If you leave your puppy in the crate for excessively long periods, he’s going to feel as though he’s being punished. (Experts recommend not allowing your puppy to spend more than four hours at a time in his crate. (Dog Crate Training Pros And Cons)


If you are away from home for long periods each day, consider engaging the services of a dog walker or a pet sitter to help break up the monotony of your puppy’s day and provide him with socialization.

A puppy’s crate should also be big enough that he has enough room to turn around and lie down, or else he may feel like he is being punished. On the flip side, ensure you don’t choose a crate that is so big that your puppy will feel comfortable going to the toilet in it.


Read more: How Much Safe is To Feed Deer Bones to Your Dog?


3. Crate training can be dangerous if precautions are not taken.

Your first goal should be to ensure the crate is put together properly. A crate constructed improperly could result in collapsing on and injuring your puppy. In addition, always remove your puppy’s lead and collar to prevent accidental choking.

Your puppy’s collar, for example, could get stuck in the door, which could result in strangulation. If you’re concerned about whether crate training is right for your puppy, talk with your vet who can offer advice on how to make the decision and tips for making the transition to the crate smoother.(Dog Crate Training Pros And Cons)



Crate training is an important tool for countless dog owners to manage behavioral problems, safely travel, and structure the housebreaking process, but it’s not perfect.

The time dogs spend in the crate must be limited and not take up the majority of their day, and the time should be strictly adjusted to your dog’s needs. Some dogs don’t tolerate much time in a crate comfortably. Alternative solutions like a dog-proofed room may help in those cases.

Crate training, when approached with understanding and patience, can be an invaluable tool for both dogs and their owners. It taps into the natural instincts of our canine companions, providing them with a sanctuary that feels both safe and familiar. However, like any training method, its success hinges on its application.


By ensuring the crate remains a positive space, balancing confinement with freedom, and addressing any concerns promptly, crate training can lead to a harmonious coexistence. Remember,(Dog Crate Training Pros And Cons)

the goal is always the well-being and happiness of your furry friend. With the right knowledge and approach, crate training can be a step towards a more structured and peaceful household. (Dog Crate Training Pros And Cons)


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Crate Training


Why is crate training beneficial for dogs?

Crate training taps into a dog’s natural den instincts, providing them with a safe and secure environment. It can aid in housebreaking, reduce destructive behaviors, and offer a familiar space during travels or stressful situations.


How long should a dog be kept in a crate?

The duration varies based on the dog’s age and needs. Puppies should only be crated for short periods, while adult dogs can handle longer durations. However, no dog should be confined for an extended time without breaks for exercise and social interaction.


Is it cruel to crate a dog?

When used appropriately, crates are not cruel. They offer a safe space for dogs. However, misuse, such as prolonged confinement or using it as punishment, can be harmful and counterproductive.


How can I make the crate more comfortable for my dog?

Add soft bedding, toys, and even an item of your clothing to make it feel homely. Ensure the crate is well-ventilated and placed in a quiet spot away from direct sunlight or drafts.


My dog hates the crate. What should I do?

Patience is key. Gradually introduce the crate using positive reinforcement. If anxiety or fear persists, consider consulting a professional dog trainer or behaviorist to address underlying issues.


Related Posts

Leave a Comment

PETCAREVIEW white logo

© 2024  All Right Reserved | Pet Care View